5 Comments
User's avatar
Batia's avatar

It is not fair or appropriate to call the Gerrer Rebbe a cult leader, despite his encouragement to get flu shots clearly being misguided. Also, many (all?) Rebbes inherit their position - this is de rigeur; this does not turn houses of Chassidus into "cults."

As far as the Mishna Brura, it's very possible that this (admittedly underwhelming) accomplishment was cherry picked by the Jewish Press.

Expand full comment
Chananya Weissman's avatar

Of course they are cults. They check off every box.

Expand full comment
Batia's avatar

This is total motzi shem ra - slander.

You quote Rav Avigdor Miller ztzl elsewhere; I never heard or read Rav Miller disparage Chassidim in any way - certainly not call them "cults."

Expand full comment
Chananya Weissman's avatar

I'm not responsible for what Rabbi Miller said or didn't say. He did make extremely sharp comments about movements within the religious world that were going against the Torah. I have the same privilege. If you disagree, that's your business.

Expand full comment
David's avatar

This video should be coupled with the article Chananya!https://rumble.com/v5rinu2-we-were-told-long-ago-flu-shots-lower-your-immune-system.html

Expand full comment